A Laurel Oak Over the Neighbor's Pool: Notes From a Site Visit

In September I looked at a 34 inch laurel oak, roughly 40 years old, with big limbs over a house and the neighbor's pool. The neighbor was worried about storms. Instead of removing the tree or thinning the inside, we recommended five to ten 2"-3" reduction cuts at the ends of the key limbs.

Why We Were There

The property manager was new to the job and catching up on maintenance that had been put off. The neighbor had raised safety concerns.

His first priority was the risk to the neighbor’s property. Keeping the tree came second, but it mattered to him.

What I Saw

  • A tree in fair condition for its age.
  • Dead tips, plus some larger dead limbs high in the crown.
  • A weakened union with a split in it.
  • Mistletoe in the canopy.
  • Old lion’s tailing, where an earlier crew stripped the inside of the limbs and left the weight at the ends.
  • Brown twig tips from twig borers, which look worse than they are.

Our page on tree defects explains unions and lion’s tailing in more detail.

The Leverage Math

Take 100 pounds off the end of a 30 foot limb and you take about 3,000 foot-pounds of leverage off the union. That is why the cuts go at the ends, where the weight does the most work, and not inside the canopy.

What We Recommended

  • Five to ten reduction cuts, about 2 to 3 inches across, at the ends of the limbs over the house and the neighbor’s pool.
  • Removing the larger dead wood in the canopy as an option.
  • Leaving the sprouts inside the canopy alone.
  • Taking out mistletoe where it is easy to reach, without chasing all of it, since full removal is unlikely to be worth the cost.
  • Getting the neighbor’s permission before working from their side of the fence.

The proposal went out with options so the decision could match the budget, and the manager planned to get a second quote, which is a reasonable thing to do.

Why the Interior Sprouts Stayed

The sprouts growing inside the canopy came from the old lion’s tailing. Pulling them out would repeat the same mistake.

Right now those sprouts are a big share of the leaves feeding the tree. Over time, a few of them can be chosen to become permanent branches.

What You Can Take From It

  • A neighbor’s worry does not automatically mean the tree has to come down.
  • Thoughtfully placed small cuts at the ends of long limbs take off more risk than heavy thinning inside.
  • Brown tips can be cosmetic. Ask before assuming the tree is dying.
  • If the crew needs the neighbor’s yard, get permission first.

Our tree pruning service handles this kind of reduction work, and a tree risk assessment is the right step when a neighbor or a board wants a documented opinion.

Laurel Oak Over the Neighbor FAQ

Not always. If the trunk and roots are sound, shortening the long limbs over the neighbor’s side can lower the risk while keeping the tree. If serious decay or a failing union turns up, removal may be the better call, and that is what the assessment is for.

Usually not all at once, and often not at all. Those sprouts are leaves the tree is using to feed itself. A few sprouts can be selected over time to become permanent branches by selectively removing some and reducing the ones you want to remain.

If the crew needs to stand in or work from the neighbor’s yard, get permission first. It also helps to tell them what is being done and why.

A Tree Worrying the Neighbors?

We will look at the tree, explain the options in plain language, and put them in writing so you can share them. The estimate is free.

Request an Assessment

Ready to Know What Your Trees Actually Need?

Request an assessment. We will walk the property, explain what we see, and give you a straightforward recommendation. No pressure, no manufactured urgency.

Request An Assessment